Angie McMahon
About

I help retirees buy and sell in Pinetop, AZ, specializing in vacation and mountain homes.

Angie McMahon

I am the Team Leader and Branch Manager at Keller Williams Arizona Realty, where I lead the Pinetop Properties Group in serving clients across Pinetop, Lakeside, Show Low and the wider White Mountains. My clients are split between people buying a summer escape from the heat or a winter retreat and people making the White Mountains their full-time home, and I work with both the same way. Whether the goal is a vacation property or a primary residence, I help clients weigh what living here actually looks like day to day, from hiking and fishing to golf and kayaking to the practicalities of a mountain property. I pride myself on extreme professionalism and a hands-on approach, often coordinating necessary repairs and contractor networks so that every transaction is smooth and stress-free.

My real estate career started in 1991, giving me 35 years of market perspective. My earlier work includes time at Long Realty Company and sales and marketing management roles at Real Property Management Rincon and Greens at Ventana Canyon. I joined Keller Williams in 2014 and served as a Productivity Coach and Trainer in the San Francisco Bay Area. I still coach agents on business planning and lead generation to build their production. For my clients, what carries over is my project management background: a structured, organized process with clear accountability from first showing to closing.

Areas
Pinetop, AZ·Lakeside, AZ·Show Low, AZ·White Mountains, AZ
Specialties
Retirees & 55+ BuyersVacation & Second Homes

Career

  1. 2024 — Present
    Realtor, Team Leader, Branch Manager · Keller Williams Arizona Realty

    Serves as Team Leader and Branch Manager, overseeing real estate operations and agent development in the Pinetop-Lakeside region.

    Team Leader and Branch Manager

  2. 2019 — 2024
    Realtor, Team Leader, Rainmaker · Keller Williams Realty Southern Arizona

    Led the Pinetop Properties Group as a Rainmaker, managing high-volume residential transactions across both Pinetop and Tucson markets.

  3. 2017 — 2019
    Realtor · Keller Williams Realty Biltmore Partners

    Specialized in vacation retreats and year-round residences in the White Mountains, focusing on Pinetop, Lakeside, and Show Low.

  4. 2016 — 2019
    Realtor, Productivity Coach/Trainer · Keller Williams San Carlos (Bay Area)

    Coached new and seasoned agents on business planning, mindset, and results-oriented lead generation strategies across Silicon Valley.

  5. 2014 — Present
    Realtor Associate · Keller Williams Southern Arizona

    Represented buyers and sellers in the Tucson, Arizona residential market.

  6. 2011 — 2014
    Sales and Marketing Manager · Real Property Management Rincon

    Managed sales and marketing initiatives for a property management firm specializing in residential rentals and investments.

  7. 2007 — 2011
    Sales & Marketing Manager · Greens at Ventana Canyon

    Led sales and marketing efforts for residential property developments.

  8. 1997 — 2003
    Realtor · Long Realty Company

    Provided residential real estate services to buyers and sellers in the Arizona market.

Education

Colorado Technical University